Justice Minister clarifies Chemmani report following controversy over Raj Somadeva’s findings

November 21, 2026 at 10:52 AM
Add as Preferred Source

By Newswire Editorial

The Government has sought to clarify the controversy surrounding the Chemmani mass grave investigations, following questions raised in Parliament over the forensic archaeological report submitted by Prof. Raj Somadeva, which has sparked debate over its findings and references to possible causes of death.

Justice Minister Harshana Nanayakkara stressed that the report was not a medico-legal assessment and would be considered alongside other forensic and investigative reports in the ongoing judicial proceedings.

Nanayakkara told Parliament that excavations at the Chemmani mass grave had recovered the remains of approximately 574 individuals through several phases of excavation.

He said the excavations were led by Prof. Raj Somadeva in the presence of the Jaffna Magistrate, legal representatives of various stakeholders, Jaffna Teaching Hospital Judicial Medical Officer (JMO) Dr. Pranavan Selliah, Criminal Investigation Department (CID) officers and scene-of-crime officers. The process continues to be monitored by legal and forensic authorities.

The Office on Missing Persons (OMP) is also actively involved as an observer under Section 12(d) of the OMP Act, the Minister said.

Responding to a question raised by MP Ramanathan Archchuna regarding Prof. Somadeva’s report, Nanayakkara clarified that Somadeva was not a forensic medical expert and had not issued a medico-legal report.

“In your question you said ‘does Raj Somadeva have the professional qualifications to issue a medico-legal report?’ No, he doesn’t and he never issued one also. This is why you have misled yourself, Sir, let me explain to you. He has never issued such a report, he has an archeological report. the report prepared and submitted by Prof. Raj Somadeva is a forensic archeological report — (examining) where, how, and under what circumstances human remains were buried. This is not a medico-legal report. the cause and manner of death will be examined through medico-legal investigations in due course in accordance with the judicial proceedings,” he said.

The Minister said the Jaffna Magistrate had directed JMO Dr. Pranavan and his team at the Jaffna Teaching Hospital to prepare a judicial forensic report on the human remains. The proceedings are underway, Nanayakkara explained.

He stressed that Prof. Somadeva’s report was only one of several reports to be considered by the Magistrate.

“I think the mistake people are making, Raj Somadeva’s report is only one of the reports the Magistrate will look at. The Magistrate cannot make an order based on one report, he will be looking at all reports, other investigation reports. The questions have got mixed up thinking that Raj Somadeva’s report is the only report, which is not the case,” he said.

Nanayakkara rejected suggestions that the archaeological findings were directed against the Tamil community, describing the report as a professional assessment intended to provide scientific information for judicial proceedings.

He said the Magistrate, following objections raised by lawyers representing families of the disappeared, had ordered that Somadeva’s report be included in the case record but not acted upon independently.

The Minister also said the government had not formally agreed to establish or facilitate an independent international investigation into the Chemmani mass grave, adding that no such request had been made by stakeholders before the court.

However, he said the government was willing to obtain international technical and forensic assistance, particularly for DNA analysis, identification of human remains and further forensic investigations, depending on the requirements identified by the court.

“We want to find the truth, we want justice. And it has to be done through a proper scientific evidence backed investigation. Race, religion, caste should not apply to this and the government does not think on those lines” Nanayakkara said.

Appealing to MPs not to politicise the Chemmani investigations, the Minister said the government was committed to ensuring a scientific and evidence-based process to establish the truth and deliver justice to the victims and their families.

“Enough is enough, racial tensions being used for political gain is an old school thing, sir, you are not doing it, I’m not saying you are. But let’s do this scientifically and properly to achieve justice and bring closure to the matter.” (Newswire)