By Newswire Editorial
The Court of Appeal has upheld the four-year rigorous imprisonment sentence imposed on Ven. Galagoda Aththe Gnanasara Thero, ruling that his statements insulting Islam and the religious beliefs of Muslims were deliberate and malicious, and could not be justified under the constitutional right to freedom of expression.
In a detailed judgment delivered on November 18, Justices P. Kumararatnam and Nawarathne Marasinghe rejected the monk’s appeal against his conviction and sentence, explaining why his statements went beyond acceptable criticism or the legitimate exercise of free speech.
The Court also made significant observations about Buddhist teachings, religious tolerance and the responsibilities of Buddhist monks to uphold moral discipline and respect other religions.
Why the Court rejected the appeal
Gnanasara Thero was convicted by the Colombo High Court on March 28, 2024, under Section 291B of the Penal Code over statements made at a media conference on November 1, 2016.
He was sentenced to two years of rigorous imprisonment on each of two charges, with the sentences ordered to run consecutively, resulting in a four-year prison term. He was also fined Rs. 50,000 on each charge.
His lawyers argued that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the statements were made with deliberate and malicious intent.
They maintained that the remarks were, at most, reckless statements and did not amount to a calculated attempt to insult the religious beliefs of Muslims.
The defence also argued that Gnanasara Thero had spoken sympathetically about poverty and social difficulties faced by Sri Lankan Muslims during the same media conference, and that the High Court had failed to consider his statements in their entirety.
However, the Court of Appeal rejected these arguments.
The judges held that the deliberate and malicious nature of the statements had to be assessed by considering the context of the media conference, the language used, the manner in which the statements were delivered, their purpose and the surrounding circumstances.
After examining these factors, the Court concluded that the statements clearly demonstrated a deliberate and malicious intention to outrage the religious feelings of Muslims.
The Court therefore found that the Colombo High Court had correctly determined that the prosecution had established the necessary ingredients of the offences.
Expression of regret cannot undo religious insults
Another significant aspect of the judgment concerned Gnanasara Thero’s expression of remorse.
During the High Court trial, the monk admitted making the statements referred to in the indictment but denied intending to hurt the religious feelings of the Muslim community.
He also expressed remorse and regret over the remarks.
However, the Court of Appeal held that an expression of regret did not remove the seriousness of the offence.
The judgment stated:
“A mere expression of regret cannot undo the seriousness of the insult made to the religion and religious feelings of the Muslim community.”
The Court considered the admission that he had made the statements an important factor in assessing the case.
Why two separate prison sentences were upheld
Gnanasara Thero’s lawyers also challenged the decision to impose two separate sentences for remarks made during a single media conference.
They argued that the two charges arose from the same occasion and questioned the decision to impose consecutive sentences.
However, the Court rejected the argument, accepting the prosecution’s position that the two charges related to two different sets of statements insulting Islam and the religious feelings of Muslims.
The judges concluded that including two separate charges in the indictment had not caused prejudice to the monk.
The Court therefore found no reason to interfere with the High Court’s decision to impose consecutive prison terms.
Freedom of speech is not absolute
The Court of Appeal also examined the constitutional protections relating to religious freedom and freedom of expression.
The judges referred to Article 10 of the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of thought, conscience and religion, and Article 14(1)(a), which protects freedom of speech and expression.
However, the Court highlighted that freedom of expression is not an absolute right.
Under Article 15(2) of the Constitution, restrictions prescribed by law may be imposed on freedom of expression in the interests of racial and religious harmony.
The judgment also referred to Article 15(7), which permits certain restrictions to protect public order and the rights and freedoms of others.
The Court’s reasoning distinguished between merely offending religious feelings and deliberately and maliciously insulting a religion.
It noted that criminal liability under Section 291B requires proof of both the prohibited conduct and the necessary malicious intention.
In reaching its decision, the Court referred to previous judicial decisions and observations of the Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka concerning religious expression, including the case involving comedian Natasha Edirisuriya.
The judgment recognised that speech which merely hurts religious feelings does not automatically constitute a criminal offence.
However, the judges determined that Gnanasara Thero’s statements satisfied the legal requirements for a conviction.
Court highlights Buddhist teachings on respecting other religions
In a notable section of the judgment, the Court of Appeal also discussed the fundamental principles of Buddhism and the standards of conduct expected from Buddhist monks.
The judges observed that Buddhism is founded on non-violence, compassion, loving-kindness and moral respect for other living beings and belief systems.
The judgment stated that Buddhist teachings recognise the existence and practices of other religions and encourage respect towards their religious leaders and followers.
The Court further referred to the Vinaya Pitaka, which establishes disciplinary rules for Buddhist monks, and the importance of right speech, right action and right livelihood in Buddhist philosophy.
It observed that members of the Sangha are expected to maintain higher standards of moral conduct, restraint and respect for the Dhamma.
The judgment noted that actions violating these principles would amount to a transgression of Buddhist monastic discipline.
Final decision
After considering the evidence, the arguments of both parties and the applicable legal principles, the Court of Appeal concluded that the prosecution had proved the charges against Gnanasara Thero beyond reasonable doubt.
Justice P. Kumararatnam held that there was no basis to interfere with the judgment delivered by the Colombo High Court on March 28, 2024.
Justice Nawarathne Marasinghe agreed with the decision.
Accordingly, the Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction and four-year rigorous imprisonment sentence, together with the fines imposed by the High Court.
The Registrar of the Court of Appeal was directed to forward the judgment and original case record to the Colombo High Court. (Newswire)

